How to Find a Reputable Car Warranty Company

Last updated February 25, 2020 by Craig Fitzgerald

If you’ve got a car registered anywhere in the United States of America, you’ve probably gotten a come-on from an extended warranty company. Probably several. Maybe dozens. They come by phone, by mail, by email, and by carrier pigeon.

In addition to these hucksters, there are reputable companies offering you a service that can actually save you thousands of dollars if a covered component were to fail during the extended warranty period.

So how do you find the good ones? 

There are a number of traits to look for that make up a decent warranty provider, and there’s research you can do to determine whether these companies are on the up-and-up. We’ll take you through the things you should be looking for.

How To Find a Car Warranty That Provides Good Protection

Covered Components

The first thing you should be considering in choosing one company over another, and one plan within that company over another, is "What does this plan actually cover?" Extended warranties and service contracts offered by the very same company can offer different tiers of protection that cover fewer items at a lower price, or add a hefty deductible if you’ve chosen the longest term of the warranty.

In almost every plan we looked at, the less expensive option either has a higher deductible, covers fewer items, or both.

The basic breakdown in types of plans are "bumper-to-bumper" plans that cover everything with the exception of regular wear items like tires, brakes, shocks, and wiper blades, and "stated component" plans that cover –- as the description suggests – stated components. For example, a plan like Endurance’s Supreme plan covers your bumper-to-bumper. But its Secure plan only covers major components like the engine, drive axles, transfer case, transmission and turbo or supercharger.

Term Flexibility

Most reputable service plans offer some level of flexibility in the term of protection. Say you buy a car and typically turn it in when it’s about six years old. A plan that offers coverage for ten years and 120,000 miles isn’t really what you’re looking for. You want to choose a plan that will offer the maximum available coverage to get you to six years after the manufacturer’s original warranty has expired.

Transferability

What if you’ve purchased an eight-year, unlimited mileage service plan and you decide to buy a new car after five years? A plan that offers a transfer of ownership for a nominal paperwork fee is not only protection for the next buyer, but it’s a selling point if you decide to sell the car privately.

Towing, Roadside Assistance and Rental

Do you pay for a towing and roadside assistance plan with an auto club? If you select the right vehicle service plan, you can save that annual fee because towing and roadside assistance are part of the service plan. If you’ve locked your keys in your car, run out of gas or had a flat tire, the service plan will send help, and if your vehicle needs to be towed, they’ll tow it to the nearest authorized dealership, getting you safely off the road.

It’s also a good idea to select a plan that offers rental assistance. Look for a plan that covers the first day rental allowance, and then provides additional days of rental allowance should your vehicle need to be at the shop for an extended period.

Trip Interruption Protection

A breakdown on the way to work is bad enough. What if your vehicle breaks down on your vacation? Look for a vehicle service plan that offers Trip Interruption Protection that can pay for up to $1,000 worth of lodging, meals and transportation expenses should your vehicle break down when you’re 100 miles or more from home.

All of these items should be a part of your overall service plan and can pay for themselves in one mechanical breakdown.

Extended Warranty Scams and How to Avoid Them

Pressure to Purchase

If you’ve gotten pitches in the mail or by phone, usually there’s some rabid sense of urgency attached. If you don’t sign on the dotted line today, you’ll NEVER BE OFFERED THIS COVERAGE AGAIN. Of course, if you’ve been around for a little while, you know that they’ll continue to offer that coverage long after you’ve sold the car to the next owner, and they’ve passed it on to their grandkids. A lot of these companies will cover anything at any time, and those are generally the extended warranty companies you want to avoid.

Reputable companies that offer this coverage realize that it’s a fairly substantial chunk of change, especially when you’re staring down the barrel of a brand new monthly car payment. That’s why on a new, or a certified pre-owned, or even a traditional used car, you can usually decide on extending the original warranty’s protection up until the point the original warranty expires.

Scary "DEMAND" Letters

Companies that send out these letters are usually preying upon older folks who often have trouble discerning the difference between important communications and junk mail. A typical letter might come from an official-sounding "Department of Automobile Records."

The red "DEMAND"-style letter had all kinds of frightening language like "Our records indicate you have received multiple notices..." and "you will be at risk of being financially liable for any and all repairs."

Only no such "department" exists, and the "Department of Automobile Records" isn’t a company at all.

"Invoices"

A lot of warranty companies use mailers that look an awful lot like invoices. They say "This is not an invoice" somewhere, usually in six point type on the second page somewhere. In bold, large print, though, is the money you’d "owe" if you actually had some particularly nasty component fail.

One of the letters we looked at from a reader contained a fairly official-looking "invoice" for nearly $13,000. The elderly woman who shared it with us had no idea how she was going to come up with the money to pay for it, not realizing that it wasn’t an invoice at all, but a pitch to get her to buy a service.

How To Stop Car Warranty Companies From Calling

The short answer? It’s largely impossible. These companies purchase MASSIVE amounts of data from car dealers, various state registries of motor vehicles, quick lube services, and any other kind of company that has anything to do with automobiles. It’s perfectly legal, and they’re going to annoy you until the end of time.

There are a handful of things you can do to avoid getting this unending barrage of advertisement, though:

By Phone

If you have a landline, you can cover yourself with the basics, like adding your phone number to the national Do Not Call registry (www.donotcall.gov) but that’s only mildly effective. Most people have caller ID at this point. If you don’t recognize the number, let it go to voicemail.

We haven’t gotten many extended warranty pitches by cell phone at this point, but chances are, that will change. Most phone services will allow you to block calls from numbers you don’t recognize, which is a pretty handy service for avoiding these companies. 

By Mail

The best thing to do is be vigilant about understanding the difference between junk mail and real mail, and you can tell immediately what it is by postage.

If it’s a bill, it’s going to come via first class mail, personalized to your address, with postage on the envelope that says "First Class Mail." This is important stuff you should open right away.

Things like catalogs, coupons, ads and junk mail from extended warranty companies come via Standard Mail. In place of a stamp or metered postage on the envelope, it will say something like "PRESORT STANDARD MAIL" and you’re safe to chuck all of this stuff right in the recycling bin.

FAQ

Q: Is there a governing body that monitors the practices of these companies?

A: There used to be. It was called the Vehicle Protection Association (VPA) and it was a non-profit that claimed to represent extended warranties and establish a code of conduct by which these companies operated. It doesn’t appear to be in service anymore, though. A visit to the website returns a not found message.

Q: What about the Better Business Bureau?

A: It’s not a great indicator of the performance of these companies. For example, one company we looked at had an A+ rating from the BBB, despite having almost 100 consumer complaints, mostly related to their predatory marketing practices, including the "DEMAND" and "Invoice" letters we mentioned above.


Editor's note and disclaimer: Car Talk is supported by our fans, readers, and listeners. When you click on some of the links on our website, we may receive referral compensation. However, you should know that the recommendations we make are based on our independent editorial review and analyses.