Infinity Car Insurance Prices and Review

Infinity Insurance is headquartered in Birmingham, Alabama, and offers insurance across four states: Arizona, California, Florida, and Texas. It was founded in 1955 as Dixie Insurance Company. Infinity is known as a company that caters to high-risk drivers and people with spotty driving records.

Review of Infinity Insurance

Independent agents sell policies, and the company offers coverage for people who might have trouble getting insurance elsewhere. This mostly includes folks who’ve had past violations, DUIs or at-fault accidents.

For that reason, Infinity is a good choice for people who might struggle to otherwise obtain insurance. That said, Infinity has been dealt more than its fair share of complaints. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners received more than an average number of complaints against Infinity in 2019. Even so, the insurer offers many of the same auxiliary benefits that top-rated insurers do.

Back to the big problem with Infinity. Slow payment of claims and unresponsive customer service agents are unacceptable in today’s world. Some customers report having to wait as many as four weeks after an accident to have a claim paid, which required them to pay out of pocket for the expenses up front. Given that the company only operates in a few states, this is likely to be a non-issue for many, but we would recommend shopping for an insurer with a more stable reputation.

Customer Reviews

Unfortunately for Infinity, the people who tend to review its insurance products are the people who are least satisfied by those products. A sampling of the juiciest Better Business Bureau reviews includes:

  • “On 11/7/2020 A driver insured by this company hit my $50,000 vehicle from behind. Completely admitted fault. I've been assigned an adjuster and given his number, every time I call the phone disconnects and doesn't give me a voicemail. I have lawyers on stand by and so does my body shop I will not tolerate these games. Your driver hit my car I need answers as soon as possible.”
  • “I was in an accident on 9/17/20 and I called in my claim early the next morning. I was told an adjuster would be contacting me within 24-48 hours. Until then I was told to have my vehicle towed from the tow yard to my house. (My car was not driveable) Obviously just to save the company money. Now being 3 days later and not hearing from anyone I have called at least 7 times so far and have been transferred around just to be disconnected. I have full coverage and I'm just trying to see what I need to do to get a rental car so I can get to and from work. This has been the worst company I have ever had to deal with. I will definitely be canceling my insurance and finding a new insurance company for my next vehicle. IF YOU ARE CONSIDERING INFINITY DO NOT DO IT!!!!” offers reviews that average 2.1 stars out of 5, but there are a few positives in the pile:

  • “I have been with this company for many years. Friendly people with very good, prompt service to fit your needs.”
  • “I thought I was paying the lowest with State Farm. Bought a van in October 2019 and the dealership ended up helping us save. We were paying $130 for one vehicle with State Farm and now are paying $130 for 2 vehicles with Infinity. Everything is the same in our policy as well. I highly recommend.”
  • “I think it's excellent company. They have a nice customer service and willing to attend at all times.”

It’s worth noting that the worst complaints against Infinity are from people who were involved in an accident with another driver who was insured by the company.

Pros and Cons

  • Solid financial strength rating
  • Can insure high-risk drivers
  • Offers several benefit programs, from roadside assistance to rental car coverage
  • Offers discount program for switching from another insurer
  • Sells policies for everything from cars to boats to RVs and ATVs
  • Only operates in four states
  • Customer service complaints are numerous
  • Policy holders complain of slow claim payment and settlement

What Is The Cost?

Infinity offers insurance products with a wide range of costs. Single male drivers in their early 30s can expect to pay around $950 for insurance, while a single male under the age of 20 might pay upwards of $2,500. Married couples have the best rates, by far, as a couple in their late 20s can expect to pay around $1,300.

Sample of annual rates for drivers with clean records:

CompanySource ASource BSource C

Here, it’s easy to see how Infinity can be more expensive in a variety of scenarios. Source A lists rates for a male driver with a clean driving record, Source B lists rates for a female in her 30s living in Houston, while Source C shows rates for a single male, age 31. In every situation, Infinity is the most expensive. This could be for a variety of reasons, and it’s important to understand that rates vary from place to place, but it pays to shop around.

Fast Car Insurance Rate Quotes

Compare quotes from multiple providers to get a good deal.

Get Quotes
Powered By:


Will Infinity Raise My Rates After An Accident?

Infinity does not list accident forgiveness in its documentation, and clearly states on its website that having an accident is grounds for the company to consider you a higher risk and to raise your rates. If you’re an Infinity customer, it’s best to stay out of trouble.

Does Infinity Offer Safe Driver Discounts?

Yes. Infinity insurance offers discounts of up to 25 percent for drivers who maintain a good driving record.

Is Infinity Good Insurance For Young Drivers?

The bottom line is that insurers don’t take too kindly to younger drivers in general. Infinity’s estimated rates for drivers under the age of 20, particularly male drivers, are astronomical, and could prove to be a real hardship for new drivers.

Is Infinity Available To Drivers With DUIs?

Yes, Infinity could be one of just a few insurers who step up to help you with your insurance needs after a DUI. Don’t expect to get discounts and don’t expect the red carpet rollout, but you should be able to get insurance.

Editor's note and disclaimer: Car Talk is supported by our fans, readers and listeners. When you click on some of the links on our website, we may receive referral compensation. However, you should know that the recommendations we make are based on our independent editorial review and analyses.