Patrick's Audi Failed Inspection: Should He Sell?

Dear Car Talk

Dear Car Talk | Apr 19, 2012

Dear Tom and Ray: I love your show. I recently got a 2001 Audi A8L that now has 130,000 miles on it. The only other owner was my dad, and he took extremely great care of the car. Recently, the check-engine light has been coming on, saying that my catalytic converter's efficiency is too low. My mechanic tested it and said the level is just barely above what I need for the car to pass its emissions inspection. He said to wait as long as I can to replace it, but that some people choose to get rid of their cars at this point because the repair is $5,200, and the blue-book value of the car is only $6,000. So, what should I do? Keep the car and pay $5,200 to replace the converters when the time comes, or sell it now, while it is still passing its emissions tests? -- Patrick

TOM: You have to relocate to somewhere with no emissions testing, Patrick. Have you considered the Democratic Republic of Congo?

RAY: A lot of people don't realize that when you buy a high-end car, it's not only the purchase price that's high -- the parts and service are "premium priced," too.

TOM: But the price you got sounds a little high even for Audi. This car uses two catalytic converters. According to our sources, the converters themselves cost about $1,900 if you buy them from Audi. Then you probably should replace all four oxygen sensors, at about $200 a pop. And then add labor. Still, I don't see how they can charge you more than about $3,500 for this job. So I think the estimate you got is high.

RAY: Not that $3,500 is cheap! But if someone offered you this car, right now, with new catalytic converters, for $3,500, you'd probably buy it, right? After all, what's your alternative? You could sell it for $6,000 and get what? A 2004 Dodge Caravan?

TOM: Or, if the buyer finds out why your check-engine light is on, you'll sell it for $2,500 and get a '94 Caravan!

RAY: You also can research aftermarket converters, Patrick. There are people who actually rebuild converters and ship them to you. You can find these guys online. Of course, you don't know what kind of quality you're getting when you go that route.

TOM: We've had some rebuilt converters that worked well, and others that didn't do enough "conversion" to keep the check-engine light off (which means you can't get an inspection sticker). So you can save some money that way, but you're taking your chances.

RAY: Since this is still a nice car, and it's been well cared for, and you seem to enjoy driving it, I'd say bite the bullet and replace the converters. But shop around first and see if you can get a better price.

Get the Car Talk Newsletter

Got a question about your car?

Ask Someone Who Owns One