Join the Car Talk Community!

You guys are pretty good at trouble shooting auto problems...

RSS
Dear Tom and Ray:


You guys are pretty good at trouble shooting auto problems, but I want to find out just how good you really are. Would it harm a car engine to tow the car forward while the manual transmission was in reverse gear? I know the answer, but unless you want to deliberately embarrass one of your readers, you won't ask how I know. In retrospect, I'm not really surprised about the consequences, but I am surprised that it happened in only a half-mile and at low speed. Even though I am hard of hearing, even I could tell that the little car (a Geo Metro being towed behind a 34 foot motorhome) was protesting mightily. Can you explain to me exactly what I did?
Robert

RAY: You goofed big time, Robert. When you're driving a car, the engine turns, and that makes the wheels move. But when you tow a car in gear, the opposite happens. The WHEELS make the ENGINE turn.

TOM: And since your manual transmission was in reverse, your wheels were making the engine turn backwards!

RAY: And engines aren't designed to turn backwards. When they do, what will often happen is that a loose timing belt will jump a few teeth, leaving the valves opening and closing at the wrong times. Then, when the pistons come flying up, they smash right into the unsuspecting valves. The result--like my brother--is not pretty.

TOM: That's probably what you did, Robert. Fortunately, it was only a Geo Metro, so you only crushed the valves on three cylinders. Had this been a real car, you would have had four four or more cylinders, and it would cost you even more to fix! 1585

Tags (Browse All)

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login / Signup
Support for Car Talk is provided by:

Donate Your Car,
Support Your NPR Station

...and get a tax break!

Get Started

Find a Mechanic


Go



Submit


Rocket Fuel