Support for Car Talk is provided by:

The Puzzler

Puzzler: Match Math

RAY: We're back. You're listening to Car Talk with us, Click and Clack, the Tappet Brothers, and we're here to discuss cars, car repair and the new Puzzler.

TOM: I'm excited! I'm really looking forward to this!

RAY: Oh, shut up!

TOM: Well you made it sound like such a big deal.

RAY: I didn't. I have two pairs of puzzlers. Each pair is related, but not to the other pair. So, I have two Puzzlers that are similar, and I have another two Puzzlers coming up in the next few weeks that are also similar.

TOM: So you like to use these, like, sequentially? The similar ones?

RAY: Nonsequentially.

TOM: All non?

RAY: Yeah. Whatever case makes...

TOM: Or chronologically.

RAY: Or nonchronologically. And the beauty of these Puzzlers is their brevity. As opposed to last week's.

TOM: And their autonomy, I suppose.

RAY: Yes, they are autonomous.

TOM: And their relatedness.

RAY: And their relatedness.

TOM: In another sense.

RAY: The first one is arithmetic, and I used this on the staff last week.

TOM: Oh, man!

RAY: And they gave us the second one.

TOM: I do remember this!

RAY: All right. Go and get a bunch of matchsticks. We'll wait. OK. Time's up. A little piece of paper and a pen, with which you can represent matchsticks. Read what the, make a fraction. The numerator of this fraction is going to be Roman numerals, OK? And the Roman numeral is 23, which is two Xs...

TOM: X-X-I-I-I.

RAY: Right?

TOM: And so you can see these being made up of matches. Two matches making up...

RAY: Anyway, there are a bunch of matchsticks, and make your line. And then the denominator is going to be 7 in Roman numerals, which is V-I-I. And then an equals sign--it's a little equation--equals 2, which is represented by two matchsticks, two vertical matchsticks, I-I. OK? Roman numeral 23, X-X-I-I-I, over Roman numeral 7, which is V-I-I, equals 2, which is I-I, capital. Obviously, this equation is wrong.

TOM: Right. It's close!

RAY: It's close enough! What the heck.

TOM: For them, it is close enough.

RAY: Your challenge is to move one matchstick and make the equation correct. Now, you cannot turn it in, you cannot take one matchstick, for example, and make it 22 over 7 does not equal 3.

TOM: That was my pretty quick solution.

RAY: Yeah, that's bogus. That's completely bogus. So, an unequals sign is not allowed.

TOM: So, the question is, How can you move one matchstick and make this into an actual equation?

RAY: There you go. Now, if you think you...

TOM: Equation! Equality! So to speak.

RAY: Yes.

TOM: And, by the way, one of the issues that came up, if I take one of the matchsticks away from the X, I will be left with a sort of diagonal-facing line...

RAY: That's bogus. That isn't...

TOM: And that means...

RAY: Nothing.

TOM: No, you can't do that.

RAY: Right. The answer.

TOM: No, you can't do that!

RAY: You can't!

TOM: You can't do that.

[ Car Talk Puzzler ]

Search Car Talk
GO
Save a boat payment. Check out our new collection of Car Talk columns.
Get the most money with the least hassle. Here's how.
What can you do other than bring fresh brownies? Tom and Ray share suggestions.
No kidding. Check out our new special edition Martin guitar.