Support for Car Talk is provided by:

The Puzzler

Puzzler, 5/16/98: Let's Hear It For The Boys

RAY: Here it is. If a mother has two kids and the older one is a boy. What are the chances the younger is a boy? OK.

TOM: Whoa.

RAY: Well, that's only half the puzzler.

TOM: I know this puzzler. This is a killer.

RAY: And the answer is 50-50. OK. You got that?

TOM: Yeah.

RAY: So, I'll give you that part.

TOM: Yeah. So, she's got a boy kid

RAY: Who's the older?

TOM: Right.

RAY: The mother has two kids. The older one is a boy, what are the chances the younger one is a boy?

TOM: Fifty-fifty.

RAY: Got it?

TOM: I'm with you on that.

RAY: You paying attention now?

TOM: Yeah.

RAY: Now, suppose that same mother. No. Suppose a different mother has two kids and one of them is a boy, what are the chances --

TOM: That the other one --

RAY: That the other one is a boy? Well, it's got to be 50-50. Right?

TOM: You would think.

RAY: Wrong.

TOM: Of course.

RAY: So, what are those chances? Now, if you're thinking --

TOM: And why? We want all the calculations, man.

RAY: I got them all right here, man. Cause Steve didn't send the answer, but, of course --

TOM: We don't need answers.

RAY: We don't need no... Oh yeah, we do need, just send the puzzler. Send the stinkin' answer.

TOM: Yeah. This is very good. Very good.

[ Car Talk Puzzler ]

Search Car Talk
GO
Watch the show online, see bloopers, and discuss the episode, "The Car of the Future."
Learn the ploys, and chat with our covert car sales operative "Deep Plaid."
Can you save money and use regular, when your owner's manual calls for premium? Find out.
Check out these tips and fork over fewer dineros at the pump.
A 20-year retrospective, this way. (Warning: Fearfully ugly faces.)
Ready to wrap your cranium around Ray's most perplexing puzzlers? Great!
From air filters to oil changes, can you DIY? Find out.