Support for Car Talk is provided by:
Check out our other recommendations
Ford Focus MINI Cooper Clubman Toyota Prius Nissan Altima Scion xD
Toyota Matrix Infiniti M35 Lincoln MKS Volvo Cross Country XC70

Infiniti EX 35

  • Incredible "top down" around-view composite parking camera system. The system uses four cameras and software, and it really works!
  • Audio safety alert system uses radar and braking measurements, to indicate that you're closing too quickly on a nearby vehicle or object. It was right, too.
  • Nice reasonable size. Not huge.
  • Great ride and comfort — opposite of hard-riding FX series
  • Small wagon-like versatility
  • Plenty of power
  • All the bells and whistles — including safety features

  • Lousy gas mileage — 19 combined
  • Rear seat knee room is minimal
  • Cargo room is compromised by the EX 35's sleek design


Kia Soul

  • We got 28 MPG, combined — not bad!
  • Cool looking car. We think it'll be the #1 back-to-college car
  • A bit over $18,000, fully tricked out with sunroof and all the accoutrements
  • Two-liter engine is entirely adequate. We'd skip the 1.6 liter, which we think might be a bit underpowered.
  • Pretty comfortable — including the back seat
  • Handles well for a little car
  • Surprisingly quiet
  • 120 month/100,000 miles power train warranty

  • Very little cargo room, especially when traveling with driver and three passengers
  • Small, so safety is a concern
  • Annoying flashing speaker display on console. (Can be deactivated.)


Hyundai Genesis

  • For a little over $30K, you can have a car that's, in many ways, comparable to a mid-level Lexus or an Infiniti, either one of which is easily $10K more. Just as when Lexus and Infiniti first came out and undercut the German cars.
  • Very comfortable ride, leans more to soft than sporty, but great for most people
  • Excellent warranty, and a good manufacturer reputation
  • Sweet engine. Six cylinder has all the power you need

  • A hint, here and there, of cheesiness and tackiness in the styling that's not present in high-end Japanese cars
  • Little prestige in driving a Hyundai, if you care about such things (we don't)


Volkswagen TDI Jetta

  • Excellent mileage
  • Much quieter than old diesels. Average driver might not even notice any additional noise most of the time.
  • Sporty handling
  • Good, practical size
  • Station wagon option

  • Clutch was a bit touchy, leading to stalling.
  • Large plastic cover over engine is designed to minimize noise. When it comes loose in a few years, the passenger cabin is going to get noisier.
  • No power in second gear. Unforgiving, if you're in second gear and driving a touch too slowly — you'll stall out.
  • Diesel fuel prices are somewhat unpredictable. If they soar, could negate the monetary savings of higher mileage.
  • Spartan feel to the car's interior
  • Seats are very firm
  • Diesels vibrate — this one included. Over time, that'll increase wear and noise.



Search Car Talk