Do I need a name brand rebuilt carburetor or can I install generic?

auto parts, carburetors
Dear Tom and Ray:

My pampered 1987 BMW 528e has 72,000 miles on it. It has been lovingly cared for and purrs like a kitten. But recently it started sounding like a B-52 bomber. The
BMW mechanic showed me the catalytic converter, and I saw where the pipe that connects to it has rusted through. He said he could replace the converter with a
"rebuilt" BMW converter for $1,300. He says it has to be a rebuilt, because BMW doesn't make new converters for my car anymore. I spoke with a non-BMW
mechanic, and he said that he could put in a new, non-BMW converter for about $700. Which way should I go? -- Carolyn

RAY: I'd go for the after-market converter in this case, Carolyn. Since the car is 13 years old, and the BMW converter costs twice as much, I'd take my chances on the
new, after-market converter for $700.

TOM: Right. After all, you can buy two of them for the price of the BMW converter. So even if they last only half as long, you'll still break even.

RAY: There are some instances when we do recommend new, factory converters to people even when they cost twice as much as after-market parts -- if the car is
relatively new and the person plans on keeping it for many years. But you're not even being offered a new part. And chances are, even the after-market converter will
last eight or 10 years. And by then, your "beloved" 528e might be your "dearly departed" 528e. Good luck, Carolyn.
Tags (Browse All)
auto parts, carburetors

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Login / Signup
Support for Car Talk is provided by:

Donate Your Car,
Support Your NPR Station

...and get a tax break!

Get Started

Find a Mechanic

Promo tile

Rocket Fuel