Join the Car Talk Community!

Car Talk Test Drive Notes

Mazda CX-5 (2013)


  • Our Grant Touring version cost $28,295 and came with a number of nice bells and whistles, including leather trimmed seats and fancy wheels. A front-wheel-drive entry-level version, with fewer accoutrements, is available for $20,695, which puts the CX-5 on a par with the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4.
  • Rides well, comfortable, and handles well.  It has probably the "sportiest" handling of the small SUVs with nicely weighted steering.  
  • Fast-acting backup camera allows you to see what's behind you, before you've smushed it, dented it or ran over its tail.
  • Blind-spot monitoring -- a feature we think every car should have. This CX-5 system works two ways. First, it's passive. If someone comes into your blind spot, a light will come on, on your rearview mirror. Second, if you have your directional signal on, and another vehicle is in your blind spot, you'll hear an audible beep.
  • SkyActiv is Mazda's branding for it's newest, modern, fuel efficient small engine design.  The two-liter, direct-fuel injection engine paired with a six-speed transmission had plenty of pep, and got us 25 mpg in mostly city driving, which is impressive.   
  • There’s a high-quality feel to the interior in our upscale, Grand Touring version.
  • The CX-5 was very quiet, even at highway speeds.
  • Excellent, small turning radius.


  • Poor visibility out the back.
  • Looking out side windows, where the D pillar is located, only negligibly helps visibility.
  • The TomTom sourced navigation system is less intuitive to program than others we've tested.  

Other notes:
Grand Touring version with All-Wheel Drive



Toyota Camry LE (2012)


  • Four-cylinder, 2.5-liter engine-- which is more than enough power for this car. It can cruise comfortably at 80 mph-- not that we would, mind you-- but it could, if one were so inclined.
  • Six-speed, automatic transmission only got to 2,000 RPM at 70 MPH, resulting in a quiet, smooth ride on the highway.
  • Without the low-profile tires that are becoming increasingly common, there's less road noise.
  • Great visibility when compared to other competitors in the same class, and especially when compared to the Ford Taurus. The excellent visibility is a nice touch for geezers, but benefits all drivers.
  • Very competent handling.  Accelerates very smoothly.
  • Good, basic transportation that will run reliably for 200,000 miles.
  • A good price, of $24k MSRP.


  • The styling is flat-out uncool-- even compared to the competing Honda Accord and Kia Optima.
  • After a one-cycle nod to styling (the previous generation), Toyota seems to have just given up and admitted that the Camry is now a geezer car.  Even the upholstery on LE says "Murder She Wrote."   Presumably, higher-end trim levels will have nicer seating. 
  • On the other hand, nice big dials and buttons for us geezers!
  • Three year, 36k warranty is a bit thin, compared to what other manufacturers are offering now. 


Fiat 500C


  • Loveably cute and original. Fun just to look at.
  • I think this is what they mean by "European Flair."
  • Fun car to drive.
  • Super easy to park.
  • Neat, airy, simple interior.
  • Very impressive tracking and handling for its size.
  • Surprisingly stable stance.
  • Very comfortable (optional) leather seats.
  • Did not feel mortally imperiled driving it, even driving at fast highway speed.
  • Nifty, powered, roll-back, canvas top. When the top is back 2/3rds, entire roof is open, but you still can see out the back through glass window. Benefits of a convertible without the structural weakness.


  • Good, but not great mileage for its size.
  • Dealers still few and far between.
  • Fiat has a long history of producing hopeless rustbuckets.
  • Doesn't feel unsafe, but objectively, it's very small and wouldn't fare well in a crash with a bigger car (i.e. practically every car)
  • Not a performance car in any sense of the word.
  • Very poor visibility out the back with the rollback top fully down.
  • Propensity to hydroplane at higher speeds.
  • Not a full convertible feel with the rolltop down, due to A, B, and C pillars at the front, middle and back of the passenger compartment.
  • Back seat is okay for a very short drive, lousy for a road trip. Another two inches of length would have made the back seat more comfortable.
  • Sure to be called a "chick" car.

Other notes:
"It's a winner in our book."



Kia Optima (2011)


  • A lot of car for the money
  • Loaded -- with heated and cooled seats, heated steering wheel, navigation, etc. -- lists for $27,500.
  • Very competitive with Accord and Camry (the Optima's less handsome corporate twin is the highly rated Hyundai Sonata).
  • Great looking exterior
  • Spacious, calming interior
  • Ergonomically sensible controls
  • Plenty powerful 2.4L four-cylinder engine. No one needs more than this.
  • Six-speed automatic transmission
  • 24 city, 34 highway in a family-sized sedan
  • Honda Accord-like size
  • Honda Accord-like feel
  • Twice the Honda Accord-like warranty (10-year powertrain)
  • Impressive ride and handling
  • Very smooth powertrain


  • Slightly firm ride, like Accord
  • Rear headroom a little tight for taller riders
  • Relative dearth of Kia dealers in many areas
  • Rear and rear-side visibility is terrible due to rising belt line.
  • Optional ($2000 Tech package) back-up camera is essential, and helps with
  • parking, but even then, you may have to go Braille. And backup camera is no help when changing lanes.
  • Electrically assisted power steering feels a bit sticky at times.


Chevy Volt (2011)


  • We've gotten a taste of the future. Very impressive engineering.
  • A real car. Just happens to run beautifully on electricity a lot of the time.
  • Treat it like a cell phone. Plug it in when when you go to bed, and start the next day all charged up.
  • Large electric capacity. 35 miles per charge all-electric under good conditions. We drove it for a week, charging it up every night, without ever using any gasoline.
  • Back up gasoline engine always ready to kick in when battery runs down, which eliminates range anxiety.
  • Seamless transition between electricity and gasoline.
  • Great, quiet, whoosh of acceleration under battery power.
  • Plenty of power for acceleration.
  • Comfortable, soft-ish ride.
  • Solid, stable handling.
  • Quiet in electric mode.
  • Hatchback practicality.
  • Blows away plug-in Prius in battery capacity.
  • $7500 Federal tax credit.


  • Electric range effected by weather, use of climate control, and driving style.
  • Can be a lot less than 35 miles under certain conditions, especially cold weather.
  • Reliability unknown, compared to well-tested Prius.
  • Small gasoline engine can be a little loud and buzzy when it kicks in.
  • Some body lean -- ride is tuned more for city driving/comfort than handling.
  • White center console's attempted "futuristic" look a bit tacky.
  • Desperately needs a rear window wiper.
  • Visibility limited due to thick A pillars and C pillars.
  • Optional backup camera should be considered a necessity.
  • Back up camera is necessary, and should be standard instead of a $600 option.
  • Should have keyless entry for $41K.
  • Noisy suspension, especially in the rear.
  • Too quiet, making it dangerous for pedestrians.
  • Gasoline vehicles just seem so "dirty" after driving the Volt!

Other notes:
Car Talk 2012 Volt Update



MINI Cooper Countryman (2011)


  • A four door MINI, with a real back seat.
  • Great, practical size.
  • Optional all wheel drive.
  • A bit of cargo room to boot.
  • No need to fear being crushed by Toyota Yarises on the highway
  • Great looks. Cool interior styling
  • Good, sporty handling
  • Available six speed stick.
  • Decent gas mileage.
  • Solid and stable on the highway.


  • Not as much fun to drive as the mini MINI
  • $35K by the time you get it all optioned up.
  • Grabby clutch
  • Firm ride. Noticeable on rough roads.
  • Some axle hop on rough curves
  • Noisy brake sounds
  • Audio controls could be a lot easier to use.
  • Inadequate reverse-lock-out on manual transmission.


Jeep Wrangler Unlimited (2011)


  • Can drive Rubicon trail with four people each having their own escape door
  • Rugged styling -- now that Hummer's gone, it's the toughest looking thing out there
  • More comfortable than two-door Wrangler due to longer wheelbase
  • Makes it possible to carry four people in a Wrangler. Two-door rear entry was difficult.
  • Some civilized interior options, like satellite radio, heated seats, and steering wheel audio controls


  • Still barbaric after all these years
  • Questionable build quality -- doors don't close well
  • Shakes, rattles, and wind noise galore
  • Pants splitter entry height
  • Fatiguing ride and disquieting handling
  • Small windshield
  • Inconvenient access to cargo area from outside
  • Only four speeds in automatic transmission
  • Lousy mileage (15-19 MPG)


Suzuki Kizashi (2011)


  • Relatively fun to drive
  • Comfortable
  • Good looks
  • Produces cabin heat quickly
  • Nice size
  • Available with all-wheel drive
  • Quiet interior
  • Excellent clutch on the manual transmission
  • Good price


  • Where's the nearest Suzuki dealer?
  • Long-term durability is an unknown
  • Some torque steer noticeable
  • Smallish backseat room


Scion tC (2011)


  • Styling
  • Predicted reliability
  • Better backseat room than you'd expect
  • Hatchback practicality
  • Decent mileage
  • Fairly comfortable front seats
  • Six-speed automatic transmission
  • Low price


  • Serious road noise
  • Muddy sound system, made worse by road noise
  • Sound system controls
  • Cheap interior, in general
  • Some transmission hunting during highway driving


Volvo S60 (2011)


  • Sleek styling, and not just "for a Volvo"
  • Most comfortable chair you'll sit in all day
  • Smooth, comfortable, powerful ride
  • Solid feel
  • Available AWD
  • Restrained but elegant interior
  • Sophisticated safety features
  • Advanced cabin electronics with relatively understandable controls


  • Mediocre gas mileage
  • Key fob AND push button combination needed to start car
  • Sticker shock: be prepared to pay 40K-plus


Support for Car Talk is provided by:

Donate Your Car,
Support Your NPR Station

...and get a tax break!

Get Started

Find a Mechanic


Go



Submit