Join the Car Talk Community!

#0848: Click and Clack's Campus Counseling: A's are Overrated!

Original Air Date: 11.29.2008

   Best Moment

Description: 
On this week's encore edition of Car Talk, college student Lea pleads for guidance though the existential crisis otherwise known as freshman year. How does she deal with the prospect of becoming an adult? And, come to think of it, why in Bluto Blutarsky's name does she think Tom and Ray can help? Also, a cross-country move gets expensive for one caller, after her Great Dane decides to see the USA from the hood of her pickup, a Mazda owner wonders what a flashing coolant light and low coolant could mean, aside from the fact that she's low on coolant, and is there any car-related sound more annoying than a mechanic endlessly repeating, "I promise, this time it really is fixed!" All that, plus greetings from the self-proclaimed Automotive Bermuda Triangle of the Midwest, this week on a special encore edition of Car Talk.

Review this Show | 30 Reviews | Need Help Listening? View Call Details

This Week's Puzzler

No puzzler this week.

Last Week's Puzzler

No puzzler this week. Find out!

Show Open Topic

Larry Walters goes for a flight... with a bunch of balloons.

Login or Register to rate and post comments

college grades

by batejani

great.

You guys sanctioned animal abuse!

by Anonymous

I completely agree with the previous reviewers who are disgusted with Hope from Atlanta who cruelly laughed at the danger she put her dog through by tethering it inadequately in the back of her open pickup truck. Even worse, you guys didn't even mention how inhumane and dangerous this is. Would you support leaving a baby in a loosely-secured or untethered car seat, or alone in a hot car? I think not, and yet this is similarly irresponsible, inhumane behavior. You should have chastised Hope, not laughed with and encouraged her stupidity and cruelty. She doesn't at all deserve the companionship of a dog if she can't more thoughtful care for it. Also, in some states (CA, NH, FL, RI, MA, VA, OR, are some), it's illegal to have a dog in the back of an open pick up truck AT ALL, or only if it is cross-tethered or in a secured crate, which clearly Hope's dog was not -- ironically, she started her trip in one of the states where her tethering method was illegal, CA (so I doubt she visited her local Humane Association as she says, since no SPCA or humane society would condone her method of transporting her dog). The ONLY humane way to travel with a dog is to keep it INSIDE the vehicle, preferably restrained in a crate or by a dog-specific harness/seat belt. If Hope or other drivers can't handle this simple and responsible action, they should have their driver's licenses -- and their dogs -- removed from their careless hands. And shame on Ray and Tom for not seeing the seriousness of this situation and failing to use their show to educate and encourage more humane treatment of dogs and all living thing.

Favorite Moment: None. I was angry and disgusted with the show, and after listening for over 12 years, I might skip it for a while.

MHC

by Anonymous

Must listening to all alums and friends of Mount Holyoke College.

Favorite Moment: When the letter writer actually calls in.

too good to miss

by cmonti

wonderful program, I wish I could have woken my wife up for - but I value my life... She looks forward to the podcast. Keep up the good work team.

Favorite Moment: The whole thing was a crazy mix of fun

Kudos to Campus Counseling

by andreajacobson@mac.com

Great advice! As a Mount Holyoke alum who is also from the Great State of Washington, I can attest to the validity of Lea's experience. Mount Holyoke College is a tough place academically speaking and the first year is probably the roughest when combine with being homesick. Fortunately, she has reached out for help early. If only I'd thought to write you guys! I didn't figure out how to enjoy college until my senior year when I decided to stopped doing all the assigned reading, wrote papers on their due dates instead of two weeks before, and instituted a "no homework" policy Friday through Sunday. After doing that, I received my highest GPA at Mount Holyoke and I was having a good time.

Favorite Moment: The best advice you guys shared was to not focus on getting "A"s and to have fun. It's all about keeping things in perspective --which is a rule that comes in handy throughout life.

The song at the end.

by jparedes

The show was one of the best. The advice for Leah was golden. The Geochemistry professor, regardless of her PhD is an idiot. The song at the end (moon light sonata?) was great. Where can we get the CD?

Favorite Moment: The song at the end.

Ignorance writ large

by Anonymous

It seems that I am the sole voice who thinks that everyone on the show was ignorant this week. The negligent professor was laughable, of course. But the rant against college was mystifying. Why do we clamor so much for universal access to education if we don't want to be educated? Surely grades aren't the only measure of education, but the dismissal of college professors as hacks who can't find other work was sad. It's no wonder we're a nation of know-nothings. Self gratification is the only imperative, it seems. Why is it that the teacher is the enemy except in overdramatized films that show the teacher as a rebel? Most teachers really want meaningful relationships with their students. Those who have grown sour and unhelpful have done so because they have been pushed away by indifference. It is hard to understand why so many students (and parents) spend so much energy resisting something that they pay so much for and seem to regard as a civil right. Why not just skip college altogether and save the debt? If Ray and Tom had any sense at all, they'd have given her that advice. Counseling Leah to stay in college and half-ass her way through is a sorry excuse for advice.

College Credit

by OhCatburn4

Loved your "B" take on the whole college thing. Amazed at your ESP on "Black" Asian car. I do want more.. Want to know the rest of that song you played. Did the light ever turn green for the guy who kept getting beeped at? Put me in the mind of Little Nash Rambler whose horn just went beep, beep, beep.

Favorite Moment: My favortie moments are always the closings... DoHe Cheatum and HOW. I love that stuff... Russian Chauffer.. Pickup and Dropoff.

Dog on the Cab - NOT!

by garirae02

Your concern for Leah was and is highly commendable. However, you should have communicated stronger derision towards the giggly, arrogant, college professor who wanted national attention for allowing her dog to "ride" on the top of her pickup cab. In California, this would be illegal, but that aside, the danger to the dog is EXTREME. That said, I can't believe that a dog wouldn't slip off the cab roof when the brakes are applied, even most slightly. That said #2: you should have instructed her to get a kennel for the truck bed and put the dog in there. Sorry, I love your show, but I just feel you missed an opportunity to tell an "intelligent" person that they are bordering on animal cruelty by garnering personal attention for such dangerous behavior.

bad advice

by vandyh

The freshman who called your show does not need to be told that all her hard work is overrated. Hard work in pursuing an education should be congratulated, and good grades are a measure of that hard work. Shame on you for not valuing an excellent education and for not supporting someone who is trying to get an education.

Pages

Lawnchair Pilot, Larry Walters

A listener shares an article about a daring aviator...

Tommy's New Theory of Learning

Tommy explains how teachers and students can stop wasting each other's time - and get down to real learning instead.

Support for Car Talk is provided by:

Donate Your Car,
Support Your NPR Station

...and get a tax break!

Get Started

Find a Mechanic


Go



Submit


Rocket Fuel